A corporate code of conduct gets its hardest test when it requires the CEO to pass up an attractive opportunity. That is the challenge Audi created for itself on October 24, when CEO Gernot Döllner appeared alongside President Donald Trump at a campaign rally in Georgia to announce plans for a $4 billion U.S. plant.
Audi's rules currently prohibit public engagements with political parties or candidates in the three months before an election. The management board authorized an exception for the appearance.
Rationale and Employee Relations
The business rationale deserves consideration. Audi has been evaluating U.S. production amid costly tariffs. An investment of this scale warrants serious engagement with the government. Audi says the appearance served the company's interests and was not an endorsement. Employees, however, are left to reconcile with the policy they are expected to follow.
Employees can judge a company's rules by how they are applied to its most senior leaders. A policy can provide for exceptions and still suffer a loss of credibility. The decision might satisfy a formal approval process while leaving people uncertain about whether the standard applies equally across the organization.
Keeping Employees Informed
Then comes the communication challenge. Döllner wrote to employees afterward, explaining that the decision had been made in the company's interest and acknowledging that the appearance was viewed as a political signal. Writing to employees was the right instinct. However, he should have sent that explanation before the event.
An advance note could have explained the commercial considerations, why the company believed an exception was justified and how it intended to maintain its broader commitment to political neutrality. Employees might still have disagreed. They would at least have heard the reasoning from their own leadership before seeing the images and reactions in the news.
Communicators sometimes worry that an early explanation will draw attention to a decision that might otherwise pass unnoticed. With a high-profile campaign event, that calculation is risky. Employees see the images, hear the criticism and form their own conclusions. By the time a follow-up arrives, even a thoughtful explanation can sound like damage control.
Creating a Safe Space for Employee Engagement
The episode also raises a question about listening. Volkswagen, Audi's parent, removed more than 200 employee comments from an internal post about the U.S. plant and disabled further comments. Volkswagen said the discussion had veered into personal attacks and violated standards for respectful exchange. Employers should enforce those standards. They also need employees to feel safe raising concerns about leadership decisions.
For communications leaders, the opportunity to influence the outcome comes well before a statement is drafted. When an executive receives an invitation to a campaign event, ask whether the same business objective can be achieved in another setting. If leadership decides to proceed, examine the policy closely and make the case for communicating the reasoning internally before the appearance.
Then prepare managers to hear employees out. Give them clear guidance on how to respond to questions without debating politics or dismissing objections. Employees can disagree with leadership's interpretation of an event and still expect their concerns to be treated fairly.
Demonstrating Values
Executives will continue meeting elected officials long after the election. Those interactions are part of business leadership. The standards for participating, and the responsibility to explain difficult decisions, should already be clear before an invitation arrives.
The strongest corporate policies survive precisely because leaders accept the constraints they impose. If an exception is necessary, employees deserve to understand why, and they deserve a meaningful chance to respond. That is how a company demonstrates that its values apply at the top.
David Grossman is CEO of The Grossman Group and a leadership and communications adviser to Fortune 500 executives.