There is an old expression in business and government about “building the plane while flying it.” It is meant to describe the challenge of making improvements while keeping an operation moving. When it comes to safety and critical infrastructure, there is little room for improvisation. Americans expect the systems they depend on every day to work, and when they don’t, they expect leaders to have answers. When those answers are slow to come, or communications are inadequate, an operational failure can quickly become a crisis of confidence.
The FAA ground stop episode last week offered a troubling case study in how not to manage a crisis, particularly at a time when a growing number of cyber-related disruptions are raising questions about the security and reliability of critical infrastructure.
Consistent Communication Is Essential to Maintaining Trust
In recent days, outages and technical problems have affected major banking institutions, Apple, United Airlines and even the National Security Agency. Combined with reports of hackers remotely manipulating commercial refrigeration systems overseas, additional questions have been raised about the vulnerability of technology Americans depend on.
When disruptions become a recurring feature, audiences cannot be expected to regain confidence through occasional statements or one-time assurances. Leaders must establish a consistent rhythm of communication, providing timely updates, explaining what is known and what remains uncertain and following through on commitments. A pattern of disruptions requires a pattern of responsible, transparent communication and reassurance.
Silence Creates an Information Vacuum
There is a fundamental difference between communicating what you know and speculating about what is unknown. No one could reasonably expect government officials to manufacture answers while technicians are still trying to identify a problem. A simple acknowledgment that multiple agencies are working around the clock, that safety remains the priority and that additional updates will follow can go a long way.
In the absence of information, fear fills in the blanks. Was this a cyberattack? Was there some foreign interference? Had the country experienced a security breach? Social media quickly filled the vacuum with speculation, jokes and conspiracy theories. Even author Stephen King joked online about aliens having landed while airspace was closing.
Uncertainty creates an environment where suspicion flourishes and confidence erodes. Americans shouldn’t have to rely on social media speculation to understand whether the systems they depend on every day are secure.
Answers Matter. So Does Accountability
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy explained that aging switches, routers and telecommunications equipment had become overloaded, creating inconsistencies in radar data and communications with aircraft. He briefed members of Congress and repeated similar messages at a press availability on Capitol Hill.
Americans deserve to know whether this was a defective piece of equipment, an installation or configuration problem or something more serious. Until the investigation is complete, officials should resist premature conclusions while providing regular updates about what they are learning.
In a crisis, the absence of new information is no excuse for the absence of communication. Silence allows others to control the narrative, and that rarely works favorably.
Leadership Means Taking Responsibility
The administration is pointing to decades of neglected infrastructure and calling for as much as $50 billion to modernize the nation’s air traffic control system. Duffy has argued that previous administrations and Congress failed to adequately address the problem. There may or may not be considerable truth to that assessment. However, blaming previous administrations, Congress or a contractor does not absolve today’s leaders of their responsibility to fix it. Leaders should avoid wasting time placing blame; and instead, take responsibility, provide answers and focus on addressing the problem.
L3Harris, which is involved in the FAA’s telecommunications modernization efforts, has also found itself in the crosshairs as questions emerge about the transition from older equipment to newer technology. Pointing fingers at a contractor is a leadership failure. Government agencies are responsible for overseeing the systems they operate, the contractors they hire and the transitions they approve. Accountability cannot simply be outsourced.
The most effective crisis management begins long before the crisis itself. It requires identifying vulnerabilities, communicating risks and preparing the public for difficult decisions. Silence over time can be just as damaging as silence during an emergency.
Reassurance Is the First Step Toward Rebuilding Trust
The administration finally seems to be getting the message, even if the response has come late. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin has given additional interviews, telling Americans to breathe, and that he could say with “98% certainty” that the country is not experiencing a cyberattack, describing the various incidents as “all individually unrelated.” Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton has also addressed the issue, stating: “Let me tell you what this is not, as far as we can tell … this is not a cyberattack, and this is not a coordinated effort by a nation state. We’ve looked very closely.”
These are important assurances, and they are precisely the kinds of direct communications Americans should have received much earlier.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio, also took time to give a full statement at a media availability despite a summit with Russia and China demanding much of his attention. While people can worry about global affairs, most are more concerned about the balances in their bank accounts and their overall safety. Rubio acknowledged that people are fearful and uncertain, saying he wanted to be clear that the United States is not under systemic attack.
“We have zero evidence or any reason to believe that any of these isolated or individual instances have anything to do with nefarious actors, with cyber hackers, with criminals, with another nation state, with a malign actor of any kind,” Rubio said.
That kind of clear, direct communication matters, particularly when public confidence is already being tested.
The administration did eventually provide more answers and made senior officials available to address legitimate public concerns. It made mistakes along the way, but the episode offers lessons for all communicators. The real measure of success will be whether these incidents lead to better oversight, stronger infrastructure, more transparency and a communications strategy that recognizes the public’s right to timely information.
Anyone can take credit when things go right. The true test of leadership is how someone responds when they don’t.
Dan Rene is a strategic communications counselor and founder of Dan Rene Communications.